Military law under the UCMJ is its own federal system, separate from state criminal law. An Article 15 is not a conviction and can usually be refused in favor of a court-martial. Article 31(b) protects a suspect before any questioning, regardless of custody. Free military defense counsel is available at a special or general court-martial.
For a servicemember who has just been contacted by an investigator, or handed a notice that a commander intends to impose punishment, questions tend to arrive in the same order: what this is, what it carries, who decides, and what happens next. Each stage has its own rules, and the decision-maker changes from one stage to the next.
Questions About the UCMJ: How Military Law Works and Why It Applies to You
If you serve in the Army, Navy, Marine Corps, Air Force, Space Force or Coast Guard, the law behind an allegation against you is the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ), codified at 10 U.S.C. Chapter 47. It is a separate federal system with its own courts and procedure, not a version of state criminal law.
The Manual for Courts-Martial (MCM) implements the UCMJ. Its rules bind, including the Rules for Courts-Martial (R.C.M.), the Military Rules of Evidence and the punitive articles. The punishment a court-martial may impose is set by the President in the MCM and depends on the offense as charged and the forum.
The UCMJ has been amended often, notably by the Military Justice Act of 2016. The version that governs is the one in force on the date of the alleged conduct. For most offenses, the decision to send charges to trial belongs to a convening authority; for certain serious offenses, recent amendments give key charging decisions to an independent special trial counsel.
Facing an Article 15? What Non-Judicial Punishment Means Before You Decide
When a commander tells you they intend to impose non-judicial punishment (NJP), the first thing to know is that it is a disciplinary step, not a trial. NJP is authorized by Article 15, 10 U.S.C. § 815. The Army, Air Force and Space Force call it an Article 15; the Navy and Coast Guard call it captain's mast; the Marine Corps calls it office hours.
The Manual describes NJP as more serious than administrative corrective measures but less serious than court-martial, and as a means of discipline "without the stigma of a court-martial conviction". It is not a conviction, and it is not a misdemeanor.
Under § 815(a), punishment generally may not be imposed if the member demands trial by court-martial first, except for a member attached to or embarked in a vessel. The notice must state the maximum punishment the NJP authority may impose and explain that charges could go to a summary, special or general court-martial (MCM, Part V, para. 4). After a demand, the commander decides whether to forward or refer charges.
Punishments include admonition or reprimand, restriction, extra duties, correctional custody, forfeiture or detention of pay and reduction in grade. For an enlisted member, forfeiture is capped at seven days' pay unless the officer is a major or lieutenant commander or above, who may impose up to one-half of one month's pay per month for two months. Under § 815(f), NJP does not bar a later court-martial for a serious offense from the same act, though the accused may show it and it must then be weighed in punishment.
Questions About Courts-Martial: What Happens if Charges Are Preferred?
By the time you hear the word preferral, the matter is in the court-martial process. Preferral is not a decision to go to trial; referral—the order sending charges to a specific court-martial—comes from the convening authority or, for covered offenses, special trial counsel.
There are three forums: summary, special and general court-martial. Each has its own punishment ceiling and procedural rights. Only a court-martial can adjudge a punitive discharge. A summary court-martial is limited to enlisted members, and no one may be tried by one over their objection.
A court-martial is a military trial, not a state criminal trial. The Military Rules of Evidence apply, and appeals go to the branch's Court of Criminal Appeals and then, on petition or certification, to the Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces.
