If you are accused under Article 128 of the UCMJ, the charge is assault: unlawfully attempting, offering or doing bodily harm to another person with force or violence. Article 128 also covers aggravated assault and assault with intent to commit certain serious offenses. Conduct toward a spouse, partner or family member may instead be charged under Article 128b.
A commander may still choose no action, administrative measures, nonjudicial punishment, or preferral of court-martial charges, and each path has its own rules, its own decision-maker and its own consequences. Knowing which stage applies, and which form of the offense is alleged, is the first step in understanding what comes next.
What Does Article 128 Actually Say About Assault?
If you have been told you are suspected of assault, the starting point is the text of the article itself. Article 128 is codified at 10 U.S.C. § 928. Its first subsection reads: any person subject to this chapter who, "unlawfully and with force or violence," "(1) attempts to do bodily harm to another person; (2) offers to do bodily harm to another person; or (3) does bodily harm to another person; is guilty of assault."
The UCMJ uses the single word "assault" to cover two kinds of conduct. One is an attempt or offer to do bodily harm, where no contact needs to occur. The other is actually doing bodily harm, which the Manual for Courts-Martial calls assault consummated by a battery. The same article then defines aggravated assault and assault with intent to commit specified offenses.
Domestic violence sits in a separate article, Article 128b, codified at 10 U.S.C. § 928b. The two articles can describe the same physical act; the difference is the relationship between the people involved and, in some forms, the intent behind the act.
The phrase "any person subject to this chapter" means the article reaches members of the Army, Navy, Marine Corps, Air Force, Space Force and Coast Guard alike. The elements and explanation for Article 128 appear in the Manual for Courts-Martial (2024 ed.), Part IV, paragraph 77. The version of Article 128 that governs is the one in force on the date of the alleged conduct.
Understanding the Three Tiers: Simple Assault, Assault Consummated by a Battery, and Aggravated Assault
When you hear that an assault charge is being considered, the form of assault alleged shapes almost everything that follows. The tiers differ in what must be proved and in how the Manual grades the punishment.
Simple assault is an unlawful attempt or offer to do bodily harm, done with force or violence. No contact is required.
Assault consummated by a battery means bodily harm was actually done to another person, unlawfully and with force or violence.
Aggravated assault, under 10 U.S.C. § 928(b), has three statutory pathways:
- offering to do bodily harm with a dangerous weapon, with the intent to do bodily harm;
- inflicting substantial bodily harm or grievous bodily harm on another person in committing an assault; or
- committing an assault by strangulation or suffocation.
A separate subsection, § 928(c), covers assault with intent to commit specified offenses. The statute lists them: murder, voluntary manslaughter, rape, sexual assault, rape of a child, sexual assault of a child, robbery, arson, burglary and kidnapping. Where the alleged intent involves a sexual offense, the Article 120 sexual assault charge is often part of the same investigation.
Terms like "dangerous weapon," "substantial bodily harm" and "grievous bodily harm" are explained in the Manual's paragraph 77. Whether the facts meet those definitions is frequently the most contested question in an aggravated assault case. The Manual also treats assault on certain persons, including a sentinel or lookout in the execution of duty, as a distinct category.
Accused of Domestic Violence Under Article 128b? Here's How It Differs
For a servicemember whose allegation involves a spouse, partner or family member, Article 128b may be the charge rather than Article 128. Congress added Article 128b through the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2020, so the date of the alleged conduct determines whether it could apply at all.
The statute, 10 U.S.C. § 928b(a), reaches any person who:
- commits a violent offense against a spouse, an intimate partner, a dating partner, or an immediate family member;
- with intent to threaten or intimidate one of those people, commits an offense under the UCMJ against any person, or against any property, "including an animal";
- with intent to threaten or intimidate one of those people, violates a protection order;
- with intent to commit a violent offense against one of those people, violates a protection order; or
- assaults one of those people by strangling or suffocating.
Article 128b is broader than assault. Some forms involve no touching of the protected person at all. The terms "dating partner," "immediate family" and "intimate partner" are defined in Article 128b itself by reference to Article 130. The underlying act may look identical under either article; the relationship, and in several forms the intent, is what moves a charge from Article 128 to Article 128b. Article 128b also carries distinct federal firearms questions, discussed under consequences below.
What the Government Must Prove in an Article 128 Case Like Yours
If you are being investigated for assault, understanding exactly what the government must prove is an important starting point. A court-martial may convict only if every element is proved beyond a reasonable doubt.
The Manual's paragraph 77 lists the elements of simple assault as:
- that the accused attempted to do or offered to do bodily harm to a certain person;
- that the attempt or offer was done unlawfully; and
- that the attempt or offer was done with force or violence.
For assault consummated by a battery, the elements are:
- that the accused did bodily harm to a certain person;
- that the bodily harm was done unlawfully; and
- that the bodily harm was done with force or violence.
The aggravated forms add what the statute requires for each pathway: an intent to do bodily harm together with an offer using a dangerous weapon, the infliction of substantial or grievous bodily harm, or strangulation or suffocation. Assault with intent under § 928(c) adds proof of the specific intent to commit one of the listed offenses.
"Unlawfully" is the element where justification and excuse, such as self-defense, come into play. The Military Judges' Benchbook contains pattern instructions that military judges use to explain these elements to a panel. Each element is a separate point the government carries, and where the evidence on any one is weak, that element becomes the focus of the defense.
What Are the Maximum Punishments Under the Manual for Courts-Martial?
When you want to know what a court-martial could actually impose, the honest starting point is that Article 128 does not say. Each subsection ends with the words "shall be punished as a court-martial may direct."
Under Article 56 of the UCMJ (10 U.S.C. § 856), a court-martial must impose punishment sufficient, but not greater than necessary, to promote justice and maintain good order and discipline, taking into consideration factors including the applicable sentencing parameters or sentencing criteria set forth in regulations prescribed by the President. In general and special courts-martial, a military judge must sentence within any applicable parameter the President has established, though the judge may impose a sentence outside that parameter upon finding specific facts that warrant it, with a written statement of the factual basis required. For Article 128, the graded limits appear in the Manual for Courts-Martial, Part IV, paragraph 77, and differ for simple assault, for battery, for each form of aggravated assault, for assault with intent to commit a specified offense, and for some categories of victim. Forum adds a second limit: a summary, special or general court-martial each have their own ceiling on punishment regardless of the offense.
A maximum is a ceiling, not a prediction. Any sentence is determined at a sentencing proceeding and does not follow automatically from a finding of guilty. Article 15 nonjudicial punishment is not a court-martial; its limits are set separately and depend on the imposing commander's grade, as covered in our guide to Article 15 nonjudicial punishment.
What Happens After You're Accused of Assault Under Article 128?
By the time you learn an allegation exists, an investigation is often already under way. Depending on the branch, the investigating agency may be Army CID, NCIS for the Navy and Marine Corps, OSI for the Air Force and Space Force, or CGIS for the Coast Guard. The way an Army CID investigation unfolds is a useful example of the stages involved.
Article 31(b) rights. Under 10 U.S.C. § 831, no person subject to the UCMJ may interrogate, or request any statement from, a suspect without first informing him of the nature of the accusation and advising him that he does not have to make any statement regarding the offense and that any statement made may be used as evidence against him in a trial by court-martial. Article 31 applies to official questioning by anyone subject to the UCMJ, including a supervisor in the chain of command, and does not depend on custody. Under § 831(d), a statement obtained in violation of the article, or through coercion, unlawful influence or unlawful inducement, may not be received in evidence against the person at a court-martial.
Preferral. If the command proceeds toward court-martial, charges are preferred: formally sworn on a charge sheet, DD Form 458. Preferral is an accusation, not a finding of anything.
Article 32 preliminary hearing. Before charges are referred to a general court-martial, a preliminary hearing is generally held unless the accused waives it. A preliminary hearing officer reviews the charges and evidence and makes a recommendation. The steps are set out in our page on the Article 32 preliminary hearing.
Referral. The convening authority decides whether the case goes to a summary, special or general court-martial, or to none.
Trial and counsel. At most special and general courts-martial, the accused chooses between trial by military judge alone and trial by a panel of members. An accused is entitled to detailed military defense counsel at no cost and may also retain civilian counsel at personal expense. How the two work together is covered in our overview of court-martial defense.
Appeal. After trial, review may run to the service Court of Criminal Appeals and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces.
Potential Defenses to Article 128 Charges Worth Exploring
If you are facing an Article 128 allegation, the existence of a charge does not mean the elements are met. The Rules for Courts-Martial recognize defenses that bear directly on assault.
- Self-defense. Force used to protect against bodily harm may be lawful where the belief that force was needed, and the amount of force used, meet the conditions the rules set.
- Defense of another. A similar defense applies to protecting a third person, with conditions tied to what that person could lawfully have done.
- Accident. An assault requires conduct that is not merely accidental. An unintended contact during lawful activity is assessed differently from a deliberate act.
- Mistake of fact. A mistaken belief about the facts can be a defense when the belief meets the standard the rules apply to the particular element.
- Consent. In narrow circumstances, consent may bear on whether contact was unlawful. This is limited and highly fact-specific.
Defenses also interact with lesser offenses. The Manual's explanation of attempts under Article 80 notes that voluntary abandonment can be a defense to an attempt, yet a person who abandoned an attempted armed robbery "may nonetheless be guilty of assault with a dangerous weapon" (MCM, Part IV, paragraph 4). A defense to one charge may not reach a completed lesser offense.
What Could Put Your Career, Reputation, or Future at Risk Beyond the Court-Martial?
For a servicemember weighing what an assault allegation means over the long term, the consequences outside the courtroom can matter as much as the sentence.
Characterization of service. Administrative characterizations are Honorable, General (Under Honorable Conditions) and Other Than Honorable. A Bad-Conduct Discharge and a Dishonorable Discharge are punitive discharges that only a court-martial can adjudge. Characterization follows a person into civilian background checks and federal employment applications, and the Department of Veterans Affairs makes its own benefits eligibility determinations in which characterization is central.
Firearms. Federal law, 18 U.S.C. § 922(g), makes it unlawful for certain people to possess firearms or ammunition in or affecting commerce. The categories include a person "convicted in any court of a misdemeanor crime of domestic violence" (§ 922(g)(9)), a person convicted of a crime punishable by imprisonment for more than one year (§ 922(g)(1)), and a person "discharged from the Armed Forces under dishonorable conditions" (§ 922(g)(6)). Whether a particular court-martial conviction falls within one of these provisions depends on the offense, its elements and the forum.
Nonjudicial punishment. NJP is not a criminal conviction but can still affect promotion, reenlistment and administrative separation.
Clearances and later review. An assault finding is often weighed in security clearance adjudication, which is a separate process with its own rules. A board for correction of military records may act on the sentence but may not set aside the findings; a discharge review board cannot review a discharge adjudged by a general court-martial.
This page provides general information, not legal advice. Laws and regulations change; consult an attorney about your specific situation.
Reviewed by Thomas P. Matthews, Esq.
California Attorney | State Bar No. 163089
Content reviewed for general legal information only. This material does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship.