Skip to content
MJDG Military Justice Defense Group

Process guide

How to Write a GOMOR Rebuttal: A Step-by-Step Guide for Army Soldiers

Published
October 28, 2026
Last reviewed
October 28, 2026
Jurisdiction
US

A GOMOR rebuttal is your written response to a General Officer Memorandum of Reprimand. You submit it to the general officer who issued it before that officer decides where it is filed. It is your chance to dispute the facts, explain the circumstances, or both. It also lets you ask that the reprimand be withdrawn or filed only locally.

If you have just signed for a GOMOR, you are at the start of a short administrative process, not a trial. A general officer has proposed a reprimand. You have a window to answer in writing, and that same officer decides what happens to the reprimand once your answer is in. Many reprimands stand alone. Some arrive alongside a CID investigation, an Article 15 or preferred charges under the UCMJ. In those situations the rebuttal is one decision among several, and it connects to the others.

Just Received a GOMOR? What It Is and What It Can Do to Your Career

If you are holding a General Officer Memorandum of Reprimand (GOMOR), the first fact to settle is what kind of action it is. It is an administrative reprimand, not a punishment under the Uniform Code of Military Justice. The Army issues it under AR 600-37, Unfavorable Information, and DA Pam 600-37 is the implementing pamphlet. Both are revised from time to time. The current revision and its date are posted by the Army Publishing Directorate, and that posted version is the one that governs.

A GOMOR is different from Article 15 nonjudicial punishment. Under 10 U.S.C. § 815, a commander may impose disciplinary punishments for minor offenses without a court-martial. Those punishments include restriction, extra duties, forfeiture of pay and reduction in grade. The limits depend on the imposing commander's grade and the member's status. Except for a member attached to or embarked in a vessel, a commander may not impose Article 15 punishment if the member has first demanded trial by court-martial.

A reprimand can itself be an Article 15 punishment. A GOMOR filed under AR 600-37 is a separate administrative tool. No reduction in rank and no forfeiture of pay flows automatically from it. Neither a GOMOR nor an Article 15 is a criminal conviction.

The reprimand ends up in one of two places:

  • Local filing. The reprimand goes into a unit-level file and does not follow the soldier after they leave the unit.
  • Permanent filing. The reprimand goes into the Army Military Human Resources Record (AMHRR, the official personnel file once called the OMPF).

The issuing general officer makes that filing decision after reviewing any rebuttal the soldier submits.

A permanently filed GOMOR is visible to promotion selection boards. It can also be cited as a basis for a bar to reenlistment or for separation proceedings. Each of those is a separate action with its own procedure. Other services use comparable administrative reprimands under their own rules. The GOMOR and AR 600-37 are Army instruments.

1. What to Look for When You First Read the GOMOR and Its Deadline

When the memorandum is first placed in front of you, three details shape everything that follows: what it says happened, who signed it, and the time available to answer.

What it says happened. The rebuttal responds to the specific allegations stated, so the exact wording matters. A reprimand for driving while impaired raises different questions from one for failing to report an incident.

Who signed it. The signer is the imposing authority, the general officer who issued the reprimand. The rebuttal is addressed to that officer.

How long you have. AR 600-37 requires that the soldier be given a reasonable opportunity to respond before a filing decision. The regulation does not reduce that opportunity to one number. The working deadline is stated in the GOMOR or in the referral memorandum that accompanies it. That document also shows what the window runs from, typically the soldier's receipt or acknowledgment. Identifying both the date and the triggering event is the first practical task.

The memorandum often states where the general officer intends to file it. A proposed AMHRR filing carries different stakes from a proposed local filing, and it shapes what the rebuttal asks for.

Any document the GOMOR relies on is worth having before drafting begins. Examples include a commander's inquiry, a police report or a test result. Soldiers commonly request copies through the unit or the legal office.

Many units also hand over an acknowledgment form on which the soldier indicates whether they intend to submit matters. That form can record an election not to respond. A soldier is entitled to understand what it says before signing it.

2. What Your Rebuttal Can and Cannot Change

For a soldier deciding whether to answer, it helps to see your rebuttal for what it is: a written submission to one decision-maker. There is no hearing. There is no cross-examination of witnesses and no right to confront the people whose statements support the reprimand. The general officer reads what is submitted and decides.

That officer generally has three options:

  1. Withdraw the GOMOR entirely.
  2. File it locally.
  3. File it permanently in the AMHRR.

A rebuttal that shows the factual basis is wrong may support withdrawal. One that accepts the facts but shows mitigating circumstances may support local filing instead of permanent filing. Neither result is assured. The choice belongs to the general officer.

Submitting a rebuttal does not pause anything else. If a court-martial, an Article 15 or an administrative separation is also in motion, those timelines keep running on their own.

The rebuttal is also not the last word. After a permanent filing, the Department of the Army Suitability Evaluation Board and the Army Board for Correction of Military Records offer later, separate avenues. They review a reprimand that has already been filed. They do not replace the chance to shape the original filing decision.

3. Gathering the Evidence and Documents Behind Your Rebuttal

By the time you begin writing, the attachments are ideally already in hand, because much of the memorandum's job is to explain them. Material soldiers commonly gather includes:

  • Performance records. The most recent NCOERs or OERs, showing sustained performance over time.
  • Awards and decorations. Commendations that speak to character and service.
  • Witness statements. Signed, dated statements from supervisors, peers or subordinates who have direct knowledge of the incident or of the soldier's conduct.
  • Character letters. Letters from commanders, senior NCOs, chaplains or civilian community members who can speak to the soldier's conduct and potential.
  • Contradicting documents. Incident reports, duty logs, messages or other records that conflict with the facts the GOMOR states.
  • Medical or behavioral health records. These matter where conditions such as PTSD or traumatic brain injury bear on the circumstances. Their release requires the soldier's authorization, and what to share is the soldier's decision.

The general officer and the legal staff review the packet closely. A document that has been altered, fabricated or selectively trimmed can undermine the whole submission and can create separate problems of its own.

4. How the Rebuttal Memorandum Is Structured and Written

Once your documents are assembled, the memorandum is where your response takes shape. Army memoranda follow AR 25-50, Preparing and Managing Correspondence, current revision at the Army Publishing Directorate. A rebuttal is commonly addressed MEMORANDUM FOR the issuing general officer, with a subject line such as "SUBJECT: Rebuttal to General Officer Memorandum of Reprimand."

Most rebuttals move through the same parts:

  1. Opening. Acknowledges receipt and states plainly whether the soldier disputes the facts, accepts them and offers mitigation, or does both.
  2. Factual response. Where facts are disputed, addresses each allegation in turn and ties it to an attachment. A general denial carries little weight.
  3. Mitigation. Gives context even where the facts are not disputed. This can include stress, family circumstances, length and quality of service, and steps already taken to address the underlying problem.
  4. Character and service. Explains what each attachment shows rather than listing exhibits.
  5. Request for relief. States the specific relief sought, usually withdrawal or, in the alternative, local filing rather than AMHRR filing.

The reader is a general officer, so the register is respectful, factual and non-adversarial. A focused memorandum, often five to eight pages with organized attachments, is easier to weigh than a long one that wanders.

Rebuttals tend to lose force in three ways:

  • They rely on emotion without facts.
  • They question the issuing officer's motives.
  • They promise future conduct without pointing to steps already taken.

Whether to concede facts at all depends on what else is pending. That question is often where an attorney's review begins.

5. Is Your Rebuttal Ready to Submit Through the Right Channel?

Is your rebuttal finished, or close to it? It generally travels to the general officer through your chain of command, usually by way of the unit S1 or adjutant.

Before handing anything over, soldiers typically keep a complete copy of the memorandum and every attachment. They also ask for written confirmation of receipt, such as a date stamp or an email acknowledgment.

If a legal assistance attorney helped with the draft, the scope of that help matters. Legal assistance attorneys advise and assist with drafting. They do not appear before the general officer on the soldier's behalf, and the relationship is limited to that assistance.

The deadline is the least flexible part of the process. When it arrives before the rebuttal is complete, a common practice is to submit what exists on time and ask in writing for more time. Whether an extension is granted is the imposing authority's decision.

AR 600-37 sets no fixed period for the general officer to decide after receiving the rebuttal. In practice the decision often comes within weeks.

6. What Happens to Your Record After the Filing Decision

After the general officer decides, your GOMOR lands in one of a small number of places.

  • Withdrawn. The reprimand is not filed.
  • Filed locally. The reprimand stays in the unit file and is generally destroyed when the soldier departs, on the terms the regulation sets. It does not travel to promotion boards or later assignments.
  • Filed permanently. The reprimand becomes part of the AMHRR. It is visible to promotion selection boards, command selection boards and separation boards.

After a permanent filing, a soldier may petition the Department of the Army Suitability Evaluation Board (DASEB). The petition asks the board to move the GOMOR from the performance section of the AMHRR to the restricted section. A transfer keeps the document in the record but removes it from promotion board view. AR 600-37 sets the criteria. They generally turn on whether transfer serves the best interests of the Army and whether the soldier has shown rehabilitation. DASEB petitions are processed periodically; the board's published guidance describes current eligibility thresholds and the documentation it expects.

The Army Board for Correction of Military Records (ABCMR) is the final administrative remedy for removing a GOMOR from the AMHRR. It is generally available after any DASEB route has been used, and its application rules are posted by the Army Review Boards Agency. ABCMR processing is commonly measured in months and can exceed a year.

The GOMOR may later be cited in a show-cause board, an elimination action, a bar to reenlistment or an administrative separation board. Each of those is a separate proceeding. Its procedure and timeline are set by the governing DoD instruction and Army regulation, not by the rebuttal process.

Parallel Proceedings and High-Stakes Situations: When Should You Speak With a Defense Attorney?

Where your reprimand arrives while investigators are still asking questions, or while charges are under consideration, the rebuttal stops being a stand-alone document.

An open investigation. A written rebuttal is a statement by the soldier. If an Army CID investigation or another law enforcement inquiry is open, what a rebuttal admits or explains can potentially be used in later proceedings. Article 31 of the UCMJ protects servicemembers against compelled self-incrimination. How that protection applies to a voluntary written submission is a question a defense attorney can review before anything is filed.

Charges preferred or a court-martial anticipated. Preferral is the formal step where charges are sworn against a servicemember. Once charges are preferred or a court-martial is anticipated, the rebuttal and the trial defense are one set of decisions, not two. A concession written into a rebuttal may sit uneasily with a plea of not guilty at trial.

Officers facing elimination. Officers who receive a GOMOR alongside a show-cause board or elimination action face several timelines at once. The rebuttal becomes one part of a larger administrative record.

Senior grades. Senior NCOs at E-7 and above, and officers, feel the effect of permanent filing more sharply. Selection boards at senior grades weigh the file closely.

Certain underlying conduct. A GOMOR tied to a sexual assault allegation, a DUI or financial misconduct may trigger reporting requirements or further administrative action beyond the reprimand itself.

In these situations, legal assistance may not be enough. Detailed defense counsel from the Trial Defense Service, or civilian counsel experienced in Army court-martial defense, can represent the soldier rather than only help with drafting.

Typical GOMOR Timeline: What to Expect From Receipt to Filing Decision

Planning the next several weeks is easier when you can see the stages in order. Every command sets its own pace, so the timing below is approximate.

  1. Receipt to rebuttal deadline. The GOMOR or its referral memorandum states the window and the event it runs from. Windows commonly fall between seven and thirty days, depending on the command. The document received controls, not a general figure.
  2. Drafting and gathering evidence. A thorough rebuttal with supporting documents realistically takes several days to a week. That can be a large share of a short window.
  3. Submission to filing decision. There is no fixed regulatory period. General officers often decide within a few weeks.
  4. DASEB petition, after a permanent filing. The board meets periodically and processing times vary. Months is a more realistic frame than weeks.
  5. ABCMR application, if pursued. Processing is commonly measured in months and can exceed a year.

Promotion board dates do not move. A GOMOR filed permanently shortly before a board convenes may be in front of that board, even if a DASEB petition is filed afterward.

Frequently Asked Questions

A permanently filed GOMOR sits in the AMHRR, where promotion selection boards see it. For officers and senior NCOs, it can effectively stop advancement. A locally filed GOMOR is generally destroyed when the soldier leaves the unit and does not follow them. The rebuttal is the soldier's opportunity to influence which outcome the general officer chooses. After a permanent filing, the DASEB can transfer the document to the restricted section of the AMHRR, removing it from promotion board view; AR 600-37 sets the eligibility criteria, which generally require the soldier to demonstrate rehabilitation and that transfer serves the Army's interests.

Related Military Defense Resources

This page provides general information, not legal advice. Laws and regulations change; consult an attorney about your specific situation.

Reviewed by Thomas P. Matthews, Esq.
California Attorney | State Bar No. 163089
Content reviewed for general legal information only. This material does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship.

Sources

Citations link to free, stable, official sources: the United States Code as published by the House Office of the Law Revision Counsel, the Manual for Courts-Martial from the Joint Service Committee on Military Justice, Department of Defense issuances, and the published opinions of the military appellate courts.

Last reviewed October 28, 2026.

Protect Your Military Career and Future.

Consultations are free and confidential. Speaking with counsel early may preserve options that are harder to recover later.

Call UsText Us