An Article 32 preliminary hearing is a limited hearing held before charges can go to a general court-martial. An impartial hearing officer, usually a military lawyer, looks at whether each charge states an offense, whether probable cause exists, and whether there is jurisdiction. The officer then recommends how the charges should be handled. The hearing does not decide guilt.
For a servicemember who has just heard the words "Article 32" from a commander or a defense counsel, the useful questions are concrete. What has already happened? Who runs the hearing? What may the accused do there? Who decides what comes next? Each stage has a different decision-maker, and many matters leave the court-martial track before trial.
Charges Preferred Against You? What Triggers an Article 32 Hearing
If you have just learned that charges against you may go to a general court-martial, the Article 32 hearing is usually the next formal step you will see. Under 10 U.S.C. § 832, a preliminary hearing generally has to be held before charges are referred to a general court-martial. The hearing is not required for a special or summary court-martial. The Manual for Courts-Martial states that failing to comply with the hearing rule has no effect on a charge that is not referred to a general court-martial.
The trigger is preferral — the formal step where charges are written out and sworn. Under 10 U.S.C. § 830, charges may be preferred only by a person subject to the UCMJ, in writing and signed under oath before an officer authorized to administer oaths. The signer states personal knowledge of the matters or that they have been investigated, and that the matters are true to the best of their knowledge and belief. The proper authority must then inform the accused of the charges as soon as practicable and decide how they should be handled.
The convening authority arranges the hearing. Before it begins, the accused must be advised of the charges and of the right to counsel. In practice, a servicemember may have detailed military defense counsel at no cost, retain civilian counsel at their own expense, or have both.
Not every matter reaches this point. A commander may take no action, or may handle misconduct through Article 15 nonjudicial punishment or through administrative separation boards. Neither of those is a court-martial conviction.
1. Who Is the Preliminary Hearing Officer Assigned to Your Hearing?
The person who runs your hearing is not a judge, and the hearing is not a trial. The statute calls this person the hearing officer. Practice commonly uses the term Preliminary Hearing Officer, or PHO.
Under § 832(a)(1)(C), the convening authority generally details the hearing officer. A different path applies when a special trial counsel is exercising authority over the charges: in that situation, the special trial counsel requests a hearing officer and the convening authority provides one.
The qualifications are in § 832(b). The officer must be impartial. Whenever practicable, the officer is a judge advocate certified under Article 27(b)(2). A non-lawyer may serve only when exceptional circumstances make it impractical to appoint a certified judge advocate, and in that situation a certified judge advocate must be available to advise the officer. Whenever practicable, the officer is also equal or senior in grade to the military counsel on each side.
Under § 832(a)(2), the hearing is limited to four questions: whether each specification alleges an offense under the UCMJ; whether there is probable cause to believe the accused committed the offense charged; whether the convening authority has court-martial jurisdiction over the accused and the offense; and what disposition should be made of the case. Guilt is not on that list.
2. What Notice, Disclosure, and Defense Preparation Come Before the Hearing?
For a servicemember in your position, the days before the hearing are when most of the defense work happens. The accused receives notice of the charges and of when and where the hearing will take place. The government's evidence for the hearing is made available to the defense under the procedures in the Manual.
The defense may also ask for witnesses and evidence, though that right is tied to the four questions the hearing decides. Under R.C.M. 405 in the Manual for Courts-Martial, the government may object that requested evidence is irrelevant, cumulative, or unnecessary. Defense counsel may then ask the hearing officer to decide. If the officer finds the evidence relevant, not cumulative, and necessary, and finds that a subpoena would not cause undue delay, the officer directs government counsel to seek one from a military judge under R.C.M. 309 or by authorization from the general court-martial convening authority. The hearing officer may not order privileged material produced but may rule on whether a privilege applies.
Article 31 applies throughout. Under 10 U.S.C. § 831, no person subject to the UCMJ may compel anyone to incriminate themselves, and anyone subject to the UCMJ who questions a suspect must first explain the accusation and the right to stay silent. Statements obtained in violation of Article 31 may not be used as evidence against the person at court-martial. The warnings often come up much earlier, during Army CID investigations and NCIS investigations.
3. What Happens at the Hearing Itself, and How Is Evidence Presented?
By the time you walk into the hearing room, the format is fairly set. The government presents evidence meant to show probable cause that the accused committed each offense charged. Witnesses may testify, or the government may rely on documents.
Under § 832(d)(2), the accused may cross-examine witnesses who testify and may present additional evidence relevant to the four issues. The accused is not required to present anything, and Article 31 means no one can compel the accused to testify. Under § 832(d)(4), questioning and evidence on both sides are limited to matters relevant to those four issues.
The hearing is not a full trial. The Military Rules of Evidence do not operate the way they do at a court-martial, although privileges and certain protections for alleged victims still apply. Under § 832(c)(1), the officer's report includes observations about whether evidence will be available and admissible at trial, which means the hearing can consider material that might never reach a panel. The hearing is recorded under § 832(e) and is generally open, though access can be restricted for classified information or an alleged victim's privacy.
Alleged victims have specific statutory rights. Under § 832(d)(3), a victim may not be required to testify at the hearing; a victim who declines is treated as unavailable, and that refusal alone cannot be the basis for ordering a deposition under Article 49. Under 10 U.S.C. § 806b, a victim has the right to notice of the hearing and may ask the Court of Criminal Appeals for a writ of mandamus if a ruling violates protections that include Article 32 and Military Rule of Evidence 412.
If evidence at the hearing points to an uncharged offense, § 832(f) allows the officer to consider it only if the accused is present, is told the nature of the uncharged offense, and has the same chance to be represented, cross-examine, and present evidence.
