If you have been convicted at a court-martial, a military appeal is a review of the trial by higher courts. It is not a new trial. Depending on the sentence, the case goes to your service's Court of Criminal Appeals, then possibly to the Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces, and rarely to the Supreme Court. Each step has its own deadline and trigger.
A finding of guilty and a sentence have been announced, and most servicemembers have never had reason to learn the process that follows. It runs in a fixed order: post-trial processing at the command, then review by the service appellate court, then a possible petition to the Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces, with a small set of collateral remedies sitting outside that ladder. Several deadlines run from the date a document is served on you, not from the day of trial.
Before You Start: What Triggers Your Right to Appeal a Court-Martial?
If you are reading this after a finding of guilty, the first thing to identify is which review path the conviction is on. The path depends on the sentence, the type of court-martial and your branch of service—not on how serious the charge sounded.
Not every conviction is reviewed automatically. Automatic review means a case goes to the appellate court whether or not the accused files anything. Article 66, UCMJ (10 U.S.C. § 866), gives a Court of Criminal Appeals automatic jurisdiction over a court-martial whose judgment includes any of these sentences:
- death
- dismissal of a commissioned officer, cadet or midshipman
- a dishonorable or bad-conduct discharge
- confinement for 2 years or more
The deciding factor is the sentence in the judgment, not the type of court-martial.
Below that threshold, Article 66 still gives the court jurisdiction over a timely appeal filed by the accused from a judgment that includes a finding of guilty. That appeal is timely if it is filed before the later of two dates: the end of the 90-day period beginning on the date the accused is provided notice of appellate rights, or a date the Court of Criminal Appeals sets by rule or order. The clock starts with that notice, not with the verdict.
A summary court-martial follows a different track. It does not carry the same automatic review right and reaches a Court of Criminal Appeals only after an application under Article 69 has been granted, as described in Step 5.
Your branch decides which court hears the appeal:
- Army Court of Criminal Appeals (ACCA)
- Navy-Marine Corps Court of Criminal Appeals (NMCCA), for Navy and Marine Corps cases
- Air Force Court of Criminal Appeals (AFCCA)
- Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals (CGCCA)
A few terms come up at every stage:
- Convening authority: the commander who referred the charges to trial and who takes the first post-trial action.
- Record of trial: the official file of the court-martial, including the transcript, the exhibits and the documents that record the findings and sentence.
- Characterization of service: the description of the quality of a person's service on discharge papers. A punitive discharge imposed by a court-martial sets it.
The documents worth having in hand are the record of trial, the convening authority's action, the entry of judgment, and the notice of appellate rights. The general court-martial process shows where each of these documents comes from.
One caution concerns the law itself. The Military Justice Act of 2016 substantially amended the UCMJ, and Congress has amended it again since. The substantive law that applies is the version in force when the conduct is alleged to have occurred, and the procedural rules are those that applied to the proceeding. Two appeals filed in the same year can follow different rules.
1. What Happens at Convening Authority Action, and What Can Be Submitted?
The moment your sentence is announced, the case does not move straight to an appellate court; it stays at the command level for a time.
The record of trial is completed first. Transcribing the proceedings and assembling the exhibits takes time, and a long trial produces a long record.
Next comes convening authority action—the commander's post-trial decision about what, if anything, to change in the result. The Military Justice Act of 2016 and later legislation narrowed that power considerably: in most cases under the current rules, the convening authority can no longer disapprove findings of guilty, and the power to reduce a sentence is limited by the offenses involved and the sentence imposed. What the convening authority may do in a particular matter depends on when the conduct occurred and which rules governed the trial.
Before the convening authority acts, the accused has the right to submit matters under Rule for Courts-Martial (RCM) 1106. That rule governs those submissions and sets their time limits, which run from a triggering event the rule identifies.
The main submission is a request for clemency: a reduction, mitigation or other relief from the sentence. If the window closes without a submission, the chance to be heard at this stage is generally lost.
Two kinds of submission are often confused. Clemency matters go to the convening authority under RCM 1106. A Grostefon submission, named for United States v. Grostefon, refers to issues the accused personally asks appellate defense counsel to put before the Court of Criminal Appeals, even where counsel does not consider them the strongest arguments.
2. What the Service Court of Criminal Appeals Reviews in a Case Like Yours
For a servicemember whose case reaches a Court of Criminal Appeals, this is usually the first time judges outside the trial examine the record. Each Judge Advocate General establishes the court for that service, and the court sits in panels of at least three judges.
The court reviews questions of law de novo—deciding them fresh, without deferring to the trial judge's conclusions. In some circumstances it may also review factual sufficiency: whether the evidence actually proves guilt, not merely whether it could. Congress has changed how that factual review works, so the standard that applies depends on the date of the offense.
Article 66 sets out what the court may do with the findings and sentence once it completes that review:
- If it sets aside findings, it may affirm a lesser included offense or order a rehearing, unless the former-jeopardy rule in Article 44 bars one. If it orders no rehearing, it dismisses the charges.
- If it sets aside the sentence, it may reduce the sentence to a lesser one or order a rehearing on it.
- If the record cannot resolve a substantial issue, it may order a further hearing.
That further hearing is called a DuBay hearing in military practice, after United States v. DuBay. It is a limited fact-finding hearing before a military judge on a specific question the appellate court identifies.
Issues commonly raised at this level include legal error at trial, factual insufficiency, ineffective assistance of trial defense counsel, and constitutional violations. Many of these appeals involve a punitive discharge—a bad-conduct discharge, a dishonorable discharge or, for an officer, a dismissal.
Appellate defense counsel is detailed (assigned) from the service's appellate defense division at no cost. The accused may also retain civilian counsel. Each Court of Criminal Appeals publishes its own rules of practice, and those rules control filing details at this level.
3. Petitioning the Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces (CAAF) and What It Decides
Once a Court of Criminal Appeals has decided, the question is whether to ask the Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces (CAAF) to hear the case. CAAF is the highest military appellate court, and its review rests on Article 67, UCMJ (10 U.S.C. § 867).
CAAF's five judges are appointed from civilian life by the President with the advice and consent of the Senate, and the court sits outside the military chain of command. Article 67 gives CAAF three paths to a case:
- Mandatory review where the sentence, as affirmed by the Court of Criminal Appeals, extends to death.
- Review on order where a Judge Advocate General orders the case sent to it.
- Review on the accused's petition, granted "on good cause shown."
The third path is discretionary review. The accused asks through a petition for grant of review, and that review need cover only the issues the grant specifies.
The deadline is written into the statute: under 10 U.S.C. § 867, the accused may petition within 60 days from the earlier of the date the accused is notified of the Court of Criminal Appeals decision, or the date a copy of that decision, after service on appellate counsel of record, is mailed to the accused by first-class certified mail. Article 67(b) states this period in mandatory terms, and a late petition generally cannot be heard.
Article 67(c)(4) provides that CAAF "shall take action only with respect to matters of law." Questions of law concern what the rules mean and whether they were applied correctly; the court does not reweigh the evidence. If it sets aside the findings and sentence, it may order a rehearing unless the reason is insufficient evidence. If it orders no rehearing, it dismisses the charges. The court's rules, cases, decisions, and notices are available at the Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces website.
4. Can a Military Appeal Reach the United States Supreme Court?
After CAAF has acted under Article 67, one further step exists, though few military cases take it. Military courts form a separate system because Article I of the Constitution gives Congress the power to make rules for governing the armed forces, and a statute sets the terms of the Supreme Court's review.
Under 28 U.S.C. § 1259, the Supreme Court may review CAAF decisions by writ of certiorari in four categories of case:
- cases CAAF reviewed because the sentence extended to death
- cases a Judge Advocate General certified to CAAF
- cases in which CAAF granted or refused to grant a petition for review
- other cases in which CAAF granted or refused to grant relief
Under the Supreme Court's rules, a petition is generally due within 90 days after entry of the CAAF judgment or order being challenged. The Court grants certiorari in a small fraction of petitions and considers questions of federal constitutional or statutory law; it does not retry facts.
Reaching the Supreme Court is not a realistic expectation in most cases. The avenue still depends on issues having been raised and preserved at the earlier stages, which is why appellate counsel tracks them from the start.
5. Collateral Attacks, Article 69 Review and Habeas Corpus After the Direct Appeal
When your conviction did not reach a Court of Criminal Appeals, or the direct appeal has ended, the remaining options are collateral remedies. A collateral attack is a challenge brought outside the ordinary appeal ladder.
Article 69 review. Under Article 69, UCMJ (10 U.S.C. § 869), the service's Judge Advocate General may act on an application by the accused or on receipt of the record. The scope of that action turns on the type of court-martial: for a summary court-martial, the Judge Advocate General may modify or set aside the findings and sentence, in whole or in part; for a general or special court-martial, the Judge Advocate General may order the case reviewed by the Court of Criminal Appeals under Article 66.
The grounds for relief are newly discovered evidence, fraud on the court, lack of jurisdiction over the accused or the offense, error prejudicial to the substantial rights of the accused, or the appropriateness of the sentence.
Article 69 review can correct errors, but it is not a full appellate proceeding. The accused may then apply to the Court of Criminal Appeals to review the Judge Advocate General's action. That court may grant the application only if two conditions are met: the application shows a substantial basis for concluding that the action was prejudicial error, and it is filed within 60 days of the earlier of notice of the Judge Advocate General's decision or the mailing of that decision by certified mail. On that review, the court acts only on matters of law.
Habeas corpus. Habeas corpus is a federal court order that requires the government to justify holding a person in custody. Under 28 U.S.C. § 2241, the writ extends only to a person "in custody," including custody under the authority of the United States. Federal district courts generally expect exhaustion of remedies first, meaning the military appellate options have already been used. Under Burns v. Wilson, federal courts ask whether the military courts gave full and fair consideration to the constitutional claim. They do not relitigate the whole case.
Administrative boards. Discharge characterization can sometimes be raised before a Discharge Review Board (DRB) or a Board for Correction of Military Records (BCMR, or BCNR for the Navy and Marine Corps). These boards are administrative, not judicial, and their power over a court-martial is limited: a correction board may act on a court-martial sentence but cannot set aside the findings, and a Discharge Review Board cannot review a discharge awarded by a general court-martial at all.
Typical Timeline: How Long Does a Military Appeal Actually Take?
By the time you are asking how long this takes, the trial may already feel like the long part. The appellate stages usually take longer, and the range depends on the service, the court's caseload and the length of the record.
Record preparation alone can take months. Court of Criminal Appeals review is commonly measured in years from docketing. A CAAF petition, briefing and decision add further time on top of that.
What does not stretch with the timeline are the deadlines. Each runs from its own triggering event, as described in Steps 1 through 5. Some can be adjusted only as a rule or order allows; others are stated in mandatory statutory terms, and missing one can close that avenue permanently.
When the Process Gets Complicated: Issues That Could Change Your Appeal Path
Some appeals leave the standard path, and your appeal may be one of them if any of the situations below apply.
Death sentences. A death sentence goes to the Court of Criminal Appeals automatically and then to CAAF for mandatory review, under Articles 66 and 67. It is subject to further review before it can be carried out.
Ineffective assistance of counsel (IAC) claims. An IAC claim argues that trial defense counsel's performance fell below the required standard. These claims often depend on facts outside the record, so they frequently require a DuBay hearing to build the record. How and when the claim is raised affects whether it is preserved.
Classified evidence. Courts-martial handle classified information under a Military Rule of Evidence modeled on the civilian Classified Information Procedures Act (CIPA). It adds procedural steps both at trial and on appeal.
Sentence relief. The convening authority's power to reduce a sentence is narrower than it once was. As a result, the appellate courts are now often the main venue for sentence relief, using their Article 66 authority to modify a sentence to a lesser one.
Separation before the appeal ends. If the accused is separated, or an enlistment ends, while the appeal is pending, questions about status and jurisdiction can arise. Separation outside the court-martial is a separate administrative track, explained in the guide to administrative separation boards.
Changes in the law. The UCMJ continues to change. Recent amendments created special trial counsel for certain offenses. Cases tried after an amendment took effect may follow different procedural rules from older cases. The overview of court-martial defense shows where those differences begin at trial.
This page provides general information, not legal advice. Laws and regulations change; consult an attorney about your specific situation.
Reviewed by Thomas P. Matthews, Esq.
California Attorney | State Bar No. 163089
Content reviewed for general legal information only. This material does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship.