Skip to content
MJDG Military Justice Defense Group

Process guide

Command Investigation in the Military: A Step-by-Step Guide for Servicemembers

Published
October 28, 2026
Last reviewed
October 28, 2026
Jurisdiction
US

A command investigation is an administrative fact-finding inquiry that a commander orders and an appointed investigating officer carries out. It is not a criminal charge or a conviction. The officer gathers evidence, interviews people and reports findings and recommendations. The commander who ordered it then decides whether to take no action, act administratively, or refer the matter for UCMJ action.

If you have just learned that you are the subject of a command investigation, and you have not told anyone yet, your questions are probably practical ones. What is this? Who is running it? What happens next? What are you entitled to at each point? The sections below follow the process in order, from the appointment through the report and what can come after it. They name the person who decides at each stage.

Before You Start: What Is a Command Investigation, and Where Does It Fit?

If your command has told you an investigation is open, start by finding out which kind of investigation it is. Each kind runs on different rules. A command investigation, often called a command-directed investigation or CDI, is an administrative tool. A commander uses it to learn what happened. It is not a criminal proceeding.

Two roles matter from the start. The appointing authority is the commander who orders the investigation and later acts on its results. The investigating officer (IO) is the officer assigned to gather the facts and report them. Under some procedures that role belongs to a board of officers.

A CDI is not the same as a law-enforcement investigation. Each service has a military criminal investigative organization:

  • Army CID for the Army.
  • NCIS for the Navy and Marine Corps.
  • Air Force OSI for the Air Force and Space Force.
  • CGIS for the Coast Guard.

These are criminal investigators. Each has its own process, covered in our guides to an Army CID investigation, an NCIS investigation and an Air Force OSI investigation.

A CDI is also separate from Article 15 nonjudicial punishment (NJP). NJP is a disciplinary proceeding a commander may offer for minor misconduct. The Navy and Coast Guard call it captain's mast, and the Marine Corps calls it office hours. It is not a court-martial and not a criminal conviction.

A CDI is also separate from court-martial charges. Those begin with preferral, the formal step where charges are sworn against a servicemember. The convening authority then decides whether the charges go to a court-martial, and which kind. This is usually a more senior commander than the one who ordered the CDI.

A CDI produces a report, not a punishment. Its findings can later support UCMJ action, administrative separation or an adverse administrative action such as a reprimand. The investigation itself is not a conviction.

Each service governs CDIs through its own publications:

  • Army: AR 15-6, Procedures for Administrative Investigations and Boards of Officers.
  • Navy and Marine Corps: the JAG Manual (JAGMAN, JAGINST 5800.7).
  • Air Force and Space Force: Department of the Air Force guidance.
  • Coast Guard: the Administrative Investigations Manual (COMDTINST M5830.1).

Step 6 compares them.

1. How a Command Investigation Begins, Often Before You Know

By the time you hear about a command investigation, it has usually been running for a while. It starts when the appointing authority names an IO in writing. That document is usually an appointment memorandum, sometimes called an appointment order.

The memorandum sets the IO's mandate. It states:

  • what the IO is to look into;
  • what questions the IO is to answer;
  • often, when the report is due.

The IO's authority comes from that document. The IO investigates the matters the appointing authority has directed, and nothing more. If the evidence points somewhere else, the IO goes back to the appointing authority for broader scope.

Common triggers include:

  • accidents and safety incidents;
  • loss of or damage to government property;
  • allegations of misconduct;
  • equal opportunity or command-climate complaints.

The governing regulation and the facts decide which kind of inquiry is used. Some matters receive only a short preliminary look. Others get a full investigation.

The Navy and Marine Corps make this split explicit. Chapter II of the JAGMAN separates a preliminary inquiry from the fuller forms of investigation. A preliminary inquiry is a quick review that helps the commander decide whether more is needed. The commander may then close the matter, handle it directly, or order a command investigation or another type of investigation.

At this stage the subject is usually not told. Nothing in the process requires notice at the moment of appointment. Commands often hold back so that witnesses are interviewed before their accounts can be shaped.

In practice, many servicemembers first learn of a CDI in one of three ways:

  • the IO contacts them;
  • a witness mentions being interviewed;
  • a supervisor tells them not to discuss a matter.

A servicemember who later sees the appointment memorandum learns two things from it: the question the commander actually asked, and the limits of the IO's authority.

2. What the Investigating Officer Does While the Investigation Runs

While the IO is working, you may notice colleagues being called away for interviews or records being pulled. That is the fact-gathering phase.

The IO collects documents, official records, physical evidence and statements from witnesses. Statements may be sworn or unsworn, depending on how the IO takes them. Either kind can end up in the report and be relied on by the appointing authority.

The IO is not a prosecutor and not a defense advocate. The IO's job is to find facts and report them to the appointing authority. The IO can still form a view, and the report will reflect that view.

When new issues come up that fall outside the appointment memorandum, the IO may ask the appointing authority to expand the scope. Expanded scope can be how a witness becomes a subject.

A witness is someone with information. A subject is someone the investigation suspects of wrongdoing or whose conduct it is examining. The label matters most at the moment of questioning. Article 31(b) protects a person who is an accused or suspected of an offense, so a shift from witness to subject brings it into play. Step 3 explains those rights.

A subject generally has no right to attend witness interviews during this phase, and no right to see evidence as the IO collects it. The subject usually learns what the evidence shows later, if at all, when adverse findings or a proposed adverse action are referred for a response.

3. What Rights Do You Have During a Command Investigation?

For a servicemember who has been contacted by an IO, or expects to be, the most important protection comes from the Uniform Code of Military Justice. Article 31(b), 10 U.S.C. § 831(b) provides that no person subject to the UCMJ may interrogate, or request any statement from, an accused or a suspect "without first informing him of the nature of the accusation and advising him that he does not have to make any statement regarding the offense of which he is accused or suspected and that any statement made by him may be used as evidence against him in a trial by court-martial."

Article 31(b) is not a civilian arrest warning. Three features set it apart:

  • It applies to anyone subject to the UCMJ who questions a suspect in an official capacity, and an IO is usually in that position.
  • It does not depend on custody.
  • It requires three things: the nature of the accusation, the advice that no statement is required, and the advice that a statement may be used at court-martial.

The article also bars compelling anyone to incriminate himself (Article 31(a)). Under Article 31(d), a statement obtained in violation of the article, or through coercion, unlawful influence or unlawful inducement, may not be received in evidence against the person at a court-martial.

Article 31(b) says nothing about a lawyer. Whether a right to counsel attaches during questioning is governed by other rules and depends on the circumstances. Separately, each service has a defense organization whose attorneys advise servicemembers at no cost. That organization's rules set who qualifies for a consultation and when.

Article 31 does not settle how a decision not to make a statement is treated in a later administrative step. That depends on the rules of the proceeding that follows, and it is one of the questions counsel can review.

The subject's opportunity to respond to the findings depends on the service regulation and on the action the command proposes. Before many adverse administrative actions, the servicemember is notified and given a chance to submit a written response. The time allowed is set by the regulation or by the notice, and it usually runs from the date of receipt. That date is worth identifying exactly.

In an informal administrative investigation there is no hearing, and the subject has no right to cross-examine witnesses. Some services provide formal procedures in which a named respondent has more procedural rights. The appointing authority chooses the procedure.

These rights differ sharply from later stages. At an Article 32 preliminary hearing, the accused has counsel and may present evidence. At a court-martial, the accused has the full protections of the Rules for Courts-Martial and the Military Rules of Evidence. A CDI offers fewer protections because it is not a trial, and that is why the decision about whether to make a statement carries weight.

4. What Happens When the Investigating Officer Writes the Report?

When the IO finishes, you may not be told right away. The report goes to the appointing authority first. It generally contains three things:

  • Findings of fact: what the IO concludes the evidence shows. These are not verdicts.
  • Conclusions: what the IO draws from those findings.
  • Recommendations: what the IO suggests the command do.

Recommendations can range widely:

  • no action;
  • counseling;
  • a letter of reprimand;
  • a General Officer Memorandum of Reprimand (GOMOR), a reprimand issued by a general officer and an Army term;
  • initiation of separation proceedings;
  • referral for disposition under the UCMJ.

The IO recommends; the appointing authority decides. The appointing authority reviews the report and may approve, disapprove or modify the findings and recommendations. The appointing authority may also send the report back for more investigation. In the Army, AR 15-6 sets out that review.

A reprimand can be filed locally or in the Official Military Personnel File (OMPF), the permanent record that promotion and selection boards review. Where a reprimand will be filed is often a separate decision. The recipient is commonly given notice and an opportunity to respond before that decision is made.

A reprimand filed in the OMPF can weigh heavily in later promotion, retention and command-selection decisions. The response is therefore often the most consequential document the subject writes in the whole process. An experienced defense attorney can review the findings, the evidence behind them and the proposed filing, and help you understand what a response can address.

5. After the Report, What Could Put Your Career or Record at Risk?

If you are waiting to hear what the command will do with the findings, there are several paths. Each one has its own decision-maker.

UCMJ action. If the appointing authority sends the matter toward the UCMJ, it becomes a separate proceeding with its own rules. Charges may be preferred, and the convening authority decides how they are disposed of. Before a general court-martial, an Article 32 preliminary hearing is generally required. The command may instead offer nonjudicial punishment.

The substantive law that applies is the UCMJ as it stood on the date of the alleged conduct. The procedural rules are those that apply to the proceeding. The Military Justice Act of 2016 changed much of the code, so the date of the conduct can matter. Our Army court-martial defense guide covers what detailed and civilian counsel each provide at that stage.

Administrative separation. Findings can support starting separation proceedings under each service's separation regulation. For enlisted members, DoD Instruction 1332.14, paragraph 5.3, requires that a respondent entitled to an administrative board be notified in writing of several things, including:

  • the basis of the proposed separation;
  • the least favorable characterization authorized;
  • the right to consult counsel;
  • the right to request a hearing before an administrative board;
  • the right to representation by appointed military counsel, or by civilian counsel at the respondent's own expense.

The same paragraph provides that failing to respond after a reasonable opportunity to consult counsel is a waiver of those rights. The board decides whether each allegation is supported by a preponderance of the evidence. The separation authority under the board procedure is a general court-martial convening authority or higher. Officers are handled under a separate process, described in our guide to officer elimination and adverse actions.

Characterization of service. This is the label the military gives to a member's service on separation. The categories include honorable, general (under honorable conditions) and under other than honorable conditions. The characterization affects eligibility for many veterans' benefits and how the service record reads to others for years afterward.

Security clearance. Adverse findings can be reported to security officials and may prompt a clearance review. Clearance adjudication is its own process, separate from the CDI.

Correcting a record later. Each department has a board for correction of military records: the Army Board for Correction of Military Records (ABCMR), the Board for Correction of Naval Records (BCNR) for the Navy and Marine Corps, the Air Force Board for Correction of Military Records (AFBCMR), and the Coast Guard's own board. These are civilian boards that can correct an error or injustice in a record. They cannot set aside court-martial findings. That path runs through military appeals.

6. How Command Investigations Differ Across the Services

Whether you serve in the Army, Navy, Marine Corps, Air Force, Space Force or Coast Guard, the basic shape of a CDI is similar. The governing publication and its terms are not. Service publications are revised often. The version that applies is the one in force when the investigation was appointed, as published in the service's official library.

Army. AR 15-6, Procedures for Administrative Investigations and Boards of Officers, is the primary regulation. It provides informal procedures, usually a single IO with no hearing, and formal procedures, which can involve a board, a legal advisor and a named respondent with additional rights. The Judge Advocate General's Legal Center and School publishes Army legal doctrine and training materials.

Navy and Marine Corps. The JAGMAN (JAGINST 5800.7) governs, chiefly in Chapter II. It separates the preliminary inquiry from the command investigation and from the litigation-report investigation, which is used when a claim or litigation against the government is expected. The Navy's Office of the Judge Advocate General publishes the JAGMAN.

Air Force and Space Force. AFI 90-301, Inspector General Complaints Resolution, governs complaints to the Inspector General. Command-directed investigations ordered by a commander follow separate Department of the Air Force guidance. An airman or guardian who is told about an "investigation" can find out which track applies, because the IG and command processes differ.

Coast Guard. COMDTINST M5830.1, the Administrative Investigations Manual, governs. The Coast Guard publishes its directives through its official directives system.

Across every service, the Article 31(b) protections described in Step 3 apply whenever a person subject to the UCMJ questions a suspect. No service regulation lowers that floor.

When the Process Gets Complicated: Red Flags That Change the Stakes

For a servicemember in some situations, a CDI is not the only thing happening. Some features change what is at stake.

A parallel criminal investigation. CID, NCIS, OSI or CGIS may be investigating the same events. The administrative and criminal tracks then run side by side. A statement given to an IO can reach criminal investigators and surface in a later court-martial, subject to Article 31(d).

A sexual assault allegation. The Army's SHARP program and the DoD-wide SAPR program add reporting and investigation requirements. A restricted report gives the victim access to support services without starting an investigation. An unrestricted report is generally referred to the military criminal investigative organization, which limits what the command's own fact-finding covers.

Command-climate or high-profile investigations. These often involve many witnesses and several subjects. That raises the chance that someone questioned as a witness becomes a subject partway through.

Inspector General involvement. An IG complaint can lead a commander to order a CDI, or the IG process can run alongside one.

An IO from outside the chain of command. When the IO is senior to the subject's chain, or comes from another unit, the subject's leaders may know little about where the investigation is heading.

Practical signals. Being told not to discuss the matter with colleagues may mean the inquiry has moved past a preliminary look. So may a request to hand over a phone, computer or records. A request to search property also raises its own questions about authorization.

How Long Does a Command Investigation Take?

If you are waiting for an investigation to end, the honest answer is that no single statute sets the length. The appointment memorandum usually sets a due date. The IO can ask the appointing authority for more time, and the appointing authority decides whether to grant it. Informal inquiries tend to move faster than formal ones, and a Navy or Marine Corps preliminary inquiry is designed to be quick. Timelines vary and no fixed end date applies in all cases.

Delays are common. Witnesses deploy, transfer or go on leave. Records can be voluminous. A request to expand scope restarts parts of the work. A legal review of the report, where the regulation or the command requires one, adds time.

The subject is often the last to learn that the investigation is over. The report goes to the appointing authority, not to the subject. Its end may first show up as one of these:

  • a notice of a proposed reprimand;
  • a referral of adverse findings for comment;
  • a separation notice;
  • a request to see the commander.

Sometimes nothing arrives, because the command took no action. Any response deadline usually runs from the date a notice is received, so that date is worth writing down.

What to Look for When Choosing a Military Defense Attorney

When you start thinking about representation, it helps to know who is available. Each service details military defense counsel at no cost. Those judge advocates represent the servicemember, not the command, and they work within a defense organization that is separate from the prosecutors. A servicemember may also retain a civilian military defense attorney at their own expense. Civilian counsel can work alongside detailed counsel or on their own.

Points servicemembers commonly weigh include:

  • experience with their own branch's investigation regulations, whether AR 15-6, the JAGMAN or Air Force and Coast Guard guidance;
  • familiarity with how CDIs become administrative or UCMJ action;
  • prior service as a judge advocate.

Questions people often put to a prospective attorney include:

  • Have you handled command investigations that led to UCMJ action?
  • How familiar are you with this branch's regulations?
  • How do you approach a written rebuttal?

Military Justice Defense Group's attorneys are licensed in California. Courts-martial and military administrative proceedings are federal matters under the UCMJ and service regulations, not state proceedings. The firm focuses on servicemembers facing investigation, charges or separation. It does not handle routine administrative matters with no potential UCMJ exposure or separation consequence. A confidential case review is where the firm looks at the documents and the timing and says whether it is the right fit.

Frequently Asked Questions

The services do not use one official list, but most investigations fall into four groups. A preliminary inquiry is a quick look to decide whether more is needed. A command investigation is administrative fact-finding ordered by a commander. A law-enforcement investigation is conducted by CID, NCIS, OSI or CGIS. An Inspector General investigation looks into complaints made to the IG. The first two and the IG process are administrative. Law-enforcement investigations are criminal.

Related Military Defense Resources

This page provides general information, not legal advice. Laws and regulations change; consult an attorney about your specific situation.

Reviewed by Thomas P. Matthews, Esq.
California Attorney | State Bar No. 163089
Content reviewed for general legal information only. This material does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship.

Sources

Citations link to free, stable, official sources: the United States Code as published by the House Office of the Law Revision Counsel, the Manual for Courts-Martial from the Joint Service Committee on Military Justice, Department of Defense issuances, and the published opinions of the military appellate courts.

Last reviewed October 28, 2026.

Protect Your Military Career and Future.

Consultations are free and confidential. Speaking with counsel early may preserve options that are harder to recover later.

Call UsText Us