Military Justice Defense Group defends servicemembers facing court-martial in every branch, from the first investigative contact through the Article 32 preliminary hearing, trial, sentencing and appeal. A court-martial defense lawyer reviews the evidence, protects the accused's Article 31 rights, challenges the government's case before and at trial, presents mitigation, and pursues post-trial review. Civilian counsel works alongside, or in place of, detailed military defense counsel.
If you have just learned you are under investigation, or a commander has told you charges are pending, you may be reading this before you have said a word to anyone. The stages ahead are predictable even when the facts are not: investigation, preferral, an Article 32 hearing for a general court-martial, referral, trial and post-trial review. The firm's work covers each of them, along with Article 15 nonjudicial punishment, administrative separation tied to an allegation, and appeals. Civilian federal prosecution, a security clearance matter standing on its own, and university Title IX proceedings are outside this practice.
Facing a Court-Martial? What It Is and How It Differs from a Civilian Criminal Trial
Hearing the word court-martial attached to your name raises an immediate question: what kind of proceeding is this? A court-martial is a federal military tribunal governed by the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ), codified at Title 10 of the United States Code. It is not a state criminal court. Its procedure comes from the Code and the Manual for Courts-Martial, published through the Joint Service Committee on Military Justice. The Manual's Rules for Courts-Martial (RCM), Military Rules of Evidence and punitive article provisions are binding; the Discussion printed beside them explains but does not bind.
There are three types of court-martial, and the type matters as much as the charge.
- Summary court-martial. A simplified proceeding before a single commissioned officer, generally limited to enlisted members and less serious offenses. Article 38's guarantee of counsel is written for general and special courts-martial and Article 32 hearings, so this forum does not carry the same right to detailed military counsel, although civilian counsel may generally appear.
- Special court-martial. An intermediate forum. One form consists of a military judge and four members (10 U.S.C. § 816(c)(1)).
- General court-martial. The forum for the most serious charges, with the highest punishment ceiling. An Article 32 preliminary hearing is generally required before charges are referred to it.
Each forum has its own ceiling on punishment. Within it, the Code does not fix a number for each offense: "The punishment which a court-martial may direct for an offense may not exceed such limits as the President may prescribe for that offense" (10 U.S.C. § 856(a)). Those limits are printed in Part IV of the Manual. Exposure in a case like yours depends on the offense as charged and the forum.
The convening authority is the commander with authority to send charges to a court-martial and to choose which kind. There is no close civilian equivalent.
Article 15 nonjudicial punishment (NJP) is a commander's disciplinary tool, not a court-martial and not a criminal conviction. A servicemember who is not attached to or embarked in a vessel can generally turn down NJP and ask for trial by court-martial instead. That choice belongs to the servicemember, and it trades one set of risks for another.
A finding of guilty at a special or general court-martial is generally treated as a federal criminal conviction. Depending on the offense and sentence, consequences can reach veterans' benefits, firearms eligibility under federal law and, for certain offenses, sex offender registration.
What Happens After You're Accused? The Court-Martial Process, Stage by Stage
By the time you are searching for the court-martial process, you may already be in its first stage. The stages run in order, though not every matter reaches every one.
Investigation. Investigations are run by Army CID, NCIS (Navy and Marine Corps), the Department of the Air Force's OSI (Air Force and Space Force) and the Coast Guard's CGIS, as well as by command inquiries. Under 10 U.S.C. § 831(b), no person subject to the UCMJ may interrogate, or request any statement from, an accused or suspect without first stating the nature of the accusation and advising that no statement is required and that any statement may be used as evidence at a court-martial. Article 31 is not Miranda. It does not depend on custody, and it binds anyone subject to the Code, including a first sergeant or division officer, not only an agent. A statement obtained in violation of the article, or through coercion, unlawful influence or unlawful inducement, may not be received in evidence against the person who made it (§ 831(d)). Whether to make any statement is the servicemember's own decision.
Preferral. Preferral is the formal step where charges are signed and sworn. The accuser is the person who signs and swears to them, directs that another do so, or has more than an official interest in the prosecution (10 U.S.C. § 801(9)).
Article 32 preliminary hearing. Before referral to a general court-martial, a hearing is generally held before an impartial hearing officer (10 U.S.C. § 832). It is not a grand jury. Its purpose is limited to whether the specification alleges an offense, whether probable cause exists, whether jurisdiction exists, and a recommended disposition. The accused may cross-examine witnesses who testify and present relevant evidence; a victim may not be required to testify. The accused can submit a written waiver, and the convening authority, or for certain offenses the special trial counsel, decides whether a hearing is still required.
Referral. Referral sends charges to a specific court-martial. The convening authority makes that decision, except that a special trial counsel now holds that authority over certain serious offenses.
Trial. The accused generally chooses between trial by members (the military panel) and trial by military judge alone. An enlisted accused may request enlisted members, and warrant officers are eligible to sit in the trial of anyone other than a commissioned officer (10 U.S.C. § 825(b)).
Sentencing. Who decides the sentence has changed. For offenses alleged after recent amendments took effect, a military judge generally sentences in non-capital cases; under earlier rules the accused could often elect sentencing by members. The date of the alleged conduct decides which applies.
Appellate review. Appeals go to the Army, Navy-Marine Corps, Air Force or Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals, then potentially the Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces (CAAF) and, in limited cases, the Supreme Court. Some review is automatic; some depends on a timely filing that runs from a post-trial event. Every deadline in the process comes from a specific rule and runs from its own starting point.
Your Right to Defense Counsel, Military and Civilian
Who will represent you, and who decides? Before a general or special court-martial, or at an Article 32 hearing, the accused may be represented by detailed military counsel, by military counsel of the accused's own selection if reasonably available, and by civilian counsel "if provided by him" (10 U.S.C. § 838(b)). Detailed counsel is a judge advocate assigned at no charge to the accused. Civilian counsel is retained at the servicemember's own expense.
When civilian counsel is retained, detailed military counsel acts as associate counsel unless excused at the accused's request (§ 838(b)(4)). The accused is not entitled to more than one military counsel, though the detailing official may add an assistant (§ 838(b)(6)). Service regulations define "reasonably available," and they may not refuse a requested lawyer solely because that lawyer serves in a different armed force (§ 838(b)(7)).
Detailed defense counsel works for the accused, not the command. Each service organises defense counsel separately from the prosecution, such as the Army's Trial Defense Service. The Navy JAG Corps and the Coast Guard each maintain military justice programs for the sea services. Under 10 U.S.C. § 801(1), the term "Judge Advocate General" includes, except when the Coast Guard is operating as a service in the Navy, an official designated to serve as Judge Advocate General of the Coast Guard by the Secretary of Homeland Security.
Civilian counsel adds different things, not a certain outcome. A civilian lawyer sits outside the military's assignment cycle, so a permanent change of station does not end the representation, and the same lawyer can carry a matter from the first interview through appeal, often with experience across branches. Many servicemembers keep both. Counsel involved before any statement is given has the most to work with, because nothing said earlier can be unsaid.
