A general court-martial moves through seven stages: preferral of charges, an Article 32 preliminary hearing unless waived, the convening authority's referral decision, arraignment and motions before a military judge, trial, post-trial review, and appeal. A case can end at several of these points, and each stage has its own decision-maker.
Before You Start: What Makes a General Court-Martial Different From Other Proceedings?
If you have been told your matter is being considered for a general court-martial, the first thing to place is where that forum sits. Article 16, UCMJ (10 U.S.C. § 816), sets out three kinds of court-martial. A summary court-martial consists of one commissioned officer. A special court-martial consists of a military judge and four members, or a military judge alone. A general court-martial, the most serious tier, consists of a military judge and eight members, a different number of members in a capital case, or a military judge alone when the accused requests it and the judge approves.
Under Article 18, UCMJ (10 U.S.C. § 818), a general court-martial has jurisdiction to try persons subject to the UCMJ for any offense the UCMJ makes punishable and may adjudge any punishment the UCMJ does not forbid, under limitations the President prescribes. Those limits are set under Article 56(a) (10 U.S.C. § 856(a)) and printed in Part IV of the Manual for Courts-Martial (MCM), offense by offense.
The governing law is the Uniform Code of Military Justice, 10 U.S.C. Chapter 47, together with the MCM. The MCM's Rules for Courts-Martial (RCM), Military Rules of Evidence and punitive articles are binding; its "Discussion" paragraphs explain but do not bind. The UCMJ has been amended many times, notably by the Military Justice Act of 2016 (Pub. L. 114-328), so the version that applies depends on when the conduct is alleged to have occurred.
The convening authority is the commander with authority to order a court-martial and decide which kind. An overview of court-martial defense across the branches compares the three forums in more detail.
1. What Does Preferral of Charges Mean for You?
When charges are preferred against you, the process has formally begun, but nothing has been decided. Preferral is the step in which an accuser swears to the charges. Under RCM 307, any person subject to the UCMJ may prefer charges, and the accuser signs the charge sheet under oath, stating that they have personal knowledge of, or have investigated, the matters set out, and that those matters are true to the best of their knowledge and belief.
The charge sheet, DD Form 458, lists the accused's personal data and unit, each charge (the UCMJ article allegedly violated) and each specification (the factual allegation under that charge).
Article 38, UCMJ (10 U.S.C. § 838), secures the right to be represented at an Article 32 preliminary hearing and at a general or special court-martial. Representation may come from civilian counsel the accused provides, from detailed counsel (military defense counsel assigned without charge), or from military counsel of the accused's own selection if reasonably available. When civilian counsel is retained, detailed counsel stays on as associate counsel unless the accused asks that they be excused. The accused is not entitled to more than one military counsel. A separate page discusses civilian court-martial lawyer fees.
Preferral is not a finding of anything. A commander may still take no action, handle the matter administratively, or offer nonjudicial punishment.
2. What Happens at the Article 32 Preliminary Hearing?
For a servicemember whose charges are headed toward a general court-martial, the Article 32 preliminary hearing is usually the next event. Article 32, UCMJ (10 U.S.C. § 832), generally requires a preliminary hearing before charges are referred to a general court-martial, conducted by an impartial preliminary hearing officer (PHO).
The statute limits the hearing to four matters: whether each specification alleges an offense under the UCMJ; whether there is probable cause to believe the accused committed the offense charged; whether the convening authority has court-martial jurisdiction over the accused and the offense; and a recommendation as to disposition.
Unlike a civilian grand jury, the hearing proceeds with the accused and defense counsel present, and the defense may cross-examine witnesses who testify and present evidence. Under R.C.M. 405 of the Manual for Courts-Martial, the PHO has no authority to issue a subpoena, but where defense-requested evidence meets the rule's standards, the PHO directs government counsel to seek a pre-referral investigative subpoena; if counsel refuses or cannot obtain one, the reasons go in writing into the PHO's report. The PHO may not order production of privileged matters but may rule on whether a privilege applies. A victim has the right not to be excluded from public portions of the hearing, except as a similarly situated victim would be excluded at trial.
The PHO's written report goes to the convening authority, who is not bound by the recommendation. The hearing need not be held if the accused submits a written waiver and the convening authority, or the special trial counsel for charges under that counsel's authority, determines that a hearing is not required. A closer look at the Article 32 hearing sets out each step.
3. Referral and the Convening Authority's Decision: Who Decides What Happens Next?
Once the PHO's report is written, the decision belongs to the convening authority, or for certain offenses to a special trial counsel. Referral, governed by RCM 601, is the formal order that charges be tried by a specified court-martial. Before deciding, the convening authority reviews the charge sheet, the PHO's report and the evidence, with legal advice from the staff judge advocate.
The options include referral to a general court-martial, referral to a special or summary court-martial, disposition outside a court-martial, dismissal of the charges, or further investigation. A pretrial agreement (generally called a plea agreement) is a negotiated agreement in which the accused agrees to plead guilty to some or all charges in exchange for terms such as limits on the sentence or withdrawal of other charges.
4. Arraignment and Pretrial Motions: Understanding Your Options Before Trial
Being arraigned is usually the first time you stand before the military judge. The charges are read and the accused is called on to plead, although entry of a plea may be deferred. The speedy-trial rule in RCM 707 generally requires that an accused be brought to trial within 120 days of the earlier of preferral or the imposition of certain pretrial restraint, with some periods of delay excluded.
Defense counsel may file pretrial motions, and the military judge rules on them. Common grounds include suppression of evidence, lack of jurisdiction, speedy trial, and unlawful command influence (UCI)—improper pressure, actual or apparent, by a commander on the court-martial process.
Forum selection happens in this window. Under Article 16(b), a general court-martial sits as a military judge and eight members unless the accused, knowing the judge's identity and after consulting defense counsel, requests trial by military judge alone and the judge approves. In a capital case, the number of members is set by Article 25a, and Article 18(b) bars a judge-alone court from trying an offense for which death may be adjudged unless the case was referred as noncapital.
5. Trial: What the Government Must Prove at a General Court-Martial
At trial, the burden sits with the government from beginning to end. The trial runs through opening statements, the government's case-in-chief, the defense case, rebuttal, closing arguments, findings and, if there is a finding of guilty, sentencing. Each element of each offense must be proved beyond a reasonable doubt.
Panel members decide findings in a member trial. Under Article 25, UCMJ (10 U.S.C. § 825), warrant officers may sit when the accused is not a commissioned officer, and enlisted members may sit when the accused is enlisted. Before assembly, an enlisted accused may personally request a panel made up entirely of officers, or one in which enlisted members are at least one-third. If physical conditions or military exigencies make that impossible, trial may proceed, and the convening authority explains why in a written statement appended to the record.
Under Article 52 (10 U.S.C. § 852), in a member trial, conviction requires the concurrence of at least three-fourths of the members present when the vote is taken. In a judge-alone trial, the judge decides. A plea of guilty is the third route to a finding.
Sentencing is a separate phase. Under Article 25(d), the military judge sentences the accused in a member trial except in a capital case. A death sentence requires a unanimous finding of guilty of an offense expressly punishable by death and a unanimous determination by the members. During sentencing, the accused may make an unsworn statement, on which the accused cannot be cross-examined.
Punitive discharges include the dishonorable discharge and, for officers, dismissal. Article 56(b) sets a minimum: for rape or sexual assault under Article 120(a) or (b), the child offenses under Article 120b(a) or (b), and attempts to commit them, the punishment generally includes dismissal or dishonorable discharge.
6. Post-Trial Review and the Convening Authority's Action: What Happens After the Verdict?
After a finding of guilty, the stage you move into is post-trial processing, and the accused still has a voice in it. Defense counsel may submit matters to the convening authority, including requests for clemency, before the convening authority acts.
The convening authority's action is the formal written decision on what, if anything, to change. The Military Justice Act of 2016 significantly narrowed that power: for many offenses and sentences, a convening authority can no longer set aside findings and has limited authority over the sentence. How far the power reaches depends on the offense, the sentence and the date of the conduct.
The trial counsel prepares the record of the proceedings under the direction of the court (Article 38(a)). The military judge then enters the findings and sentence into the record as the entry of judgment under Article 60c, which is what an appellate court later reviews.
7. Appeals: How the Military Appellate Courts Review a Conviction
Where a conviction stands after post-trial review, your next stage is appellate review by the military courts. Each service has a Court of Criminal Appeals (CCA): the Army Court of Criminal Appeals, the Navy-Marine Corps Court of Criminal Appeals, the Air Force Court of Criminal Appeals and the Coast Guard Court of Criminal Appeals. Article 66 (10 U.S.C. § 866) sets which cases a CCA reviews and whether the accused files the appeal, depending on the sentence and when the case was tried.
Under Article 66(d), the CCA acts only on the findings and sentence as entered into the record, and may affirm only findings it finds correct in law and in fact. The court may consider factual sufficiency on the accused's request, after a specific showing of a deficiency in proof, then weighs the evidence with deference to the trial court and to the judge's findings of fact. If clearly convinced a finding was against the weight of the evidence, the court may dismiss, set aside or modify it, or affirm a lesser finding.
Above the CCAs is the Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces, a court of civilian judges appointed by the President and confirmed by the Senate. Under Article 67(b) (10 U.S.C. § 867), the accused may petition CAAF within 60 days from the earlier of notification of the CCA's decision or the date a copy, after service on appellate counsel of record, is mailed by first-class certified mail to the accused's provided address or latest address in the service record. After acting on a case, CAAF may direct the Judge Advocate General to return the record to the CCA for further review; if a rehearing is ordered but the convening authority finds it impracticable, the charges may be dismissed.
In limited circumstances, the Supreme Court may review a CAAF decision by writ of certiorari. Each service's appellate defense division provides appellate defense counsel without charge.
Typical Timeline: How Long Does a General Court-Martial Actually Take?
How long all of this takes depends on the stage and the complexity of the charges. Preferral to the Article 32 hearing commonly takes weeks to a few months. Referral can follow the PHO's report within days or weeks. Arraignment typically follows referral within weeks, and the RCM 707 clock runs in the background. A contested trial may last days or weeks. Post-trial processing commonly takes weeks to months. CCA review can take a year or more, and a CAAF petition adds more. None of these ranges is a promise about any particular matter.
When the Process Gets Complicated: Issues That Could Change the Path Ahead
Some features of the charges can change the standard sequence. Under Article 18(c), only a general court-martial may try rape or sexual assault under Article 120(a) or (b), the child offenses under Article 120b(a) or (b), and attempts to commit them. These offenses typically involve a special trial counsel and victims' counsel. The page on Article 120 sexual assault charges covers the elements. For attempts, MCM Part IV, paragraph 4 applies the maximum for the offense attempted, bars death, caps confinement at 20 years except for attempted murder, and keeps mandatory minimums for attempted rape and sexual assault under Article 120(a) or (b) and Article 120b(a) or (b).
Pretrial confinement may be ordered before trial under rules that provide for review. Article 13 (10 U.S.C. § 813) provides that no person held for trial may be subjected to punishment or penalty other than arrest or confinement upon the charges pending against them, nor to confinement more rigorous than the circumstances require to insure presence, though minor punishment for infractions of discipline is permitted.
A punitive discharge differs from an administrative separation, which is not a court-martial sentence; administrative separation boards follow a different process. A board for correction of military records may act on a court-martial sentence but cannot set aside the findings, and a discharge review board cannot review a discharge awarded by a general court-martial.
This page provides general information, not legal advice. Laws and regulations change; consult an attorney about your specific situation.
Reviewed by Thomas P. Matthews, Esq.
California Attorney | State Bar No. 163089
Content reviewed for general legal information only. This material does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship.