If you have been told you may face an Article 92 charge, the article itself is short: it punishes three separate offenses. They are violating a lawful general order or regulation, failing to obey another lawful order the accused knew of and had a duty to obey, and dereliction in the performance of duties. Each has its own elements and punishment limits.
For a servicemember who has just been read Article 31 rights, handed a charge sheet, or told a commander is considering nonjudicial punishment, the first question is usually what this actually means. The answer turns on which of the three offenses is alleged, which stage the matter has reached, and which service's procedures apply. Much of that can be read from paperwork the servicemember may already have.
What Does Article 92 Actually Cover?
If you assumed Article 92 was only about refusing a direct order, the text reaches further than that. It is codified at 10 U.S.C. § 892. It applies to any person subject to the UCMJ who "(1) violates or fails to obey any lawful general order or regulation; (2) having knowledge of any other lawful order issued by a member of the armed forces, which it is his duty to obey, fails to obey the order; or (3) is derelict in the performance of his duties." It ends: "shall be punished as a court-martial may direct."
That is three offenses, not one. The second clause covers an order "issued by a member of the armed forces," not only one issued by a commissioned officer. Articles 90 and 91 cover narrower ground and are addressed further below.
The article does not list elements or punishments. Under 10 U.S.C. § 856(a), "The punishment which a court-martial may direct for an offense may not exceed such limits as the President may prescribe for that offense." Those limits, and the elements, appear in the Manual for Courts-Martial (2024 ed.), Part IV, paragraph 18, published by the Joint Service Committee on Military Justice.
The Manual contains both binding rules (the Rules for Courts-Martial, the Military Rules of Evidence and the punitive articles) and explanatory Discussion, which is not binding. The version that governs is the one in force on the date of the alleged conduct.
What the Government Must Prove in an Article 92 Case
When an Article 92 specification is drafted against you, it names one of the three offenses. Which offense it names determines what the government must prove.
Violating a lawful general order or regulation. The government generally must show that a lawful general order or regulation was in effect, that the accused had a duty to obey it, and that the accused violated or failed to obey it. Knowledge is generally not an element. A general order binds the people within its scope whether or not they personally read it. General orders and regulations are generally those issued by the President, the Secretary of Defense, a Secretary of a military department, or certain senior commanders with authority to issue them. Not every regulation qualifies; it generally must set out rules that individuals are required to follow, not only guidance.
Failing to obey another lawful order. Here the statute itself requires "knowledge." The government must show that a member of the armed forces issued a lawful order, that the accused knew of it, that the accused had a duty to obey it, and that the accused failed to obey. Knowledge may be proved by circumstantial evidence.
Dereliction of duty. The government generally must show that the accused had certain duties, that the accused knew or reasonably should have known of them, and that the accused was derelict in performing them. Dereliction may be willful, negligent or through culpable inefficiency. The Manual, paragraph 18 defines "negligently" as an act or omission that "exhibits a lack of that degree of care which a reasonably prudent person would have exercised under the same or similar circumstances." It describes culpable inefficiency as "inefficiency for which there is no reasonable or just excuse." It also draws a line: a person "is not derelict in the performance of duties if the failure to perform those duties is caused by ineptitude rather than by willfulness, negligence, or culpable inefficiency."
What makes an order lawful. Orders are generally presumed lawful. To be lawful, an order generally must have a valid military purpose. It must not require the commission of a crime or conflict with the Constitution or other law. Whether an order was lawful is a question of law decided by the military judge, not by the members (the military jury).
What Happens After You're Accused of an Article 92 Violation?
By the time someone in the chain of command mentions Article 92 to you, the matter has usually reached one of a few points. Many begin with a command inquiry. Others begin with an investigation by a military criminal investigative organization: Army CID, NCIS for the Navy and Marine Corps, OSI for the Air Force and Space Force, or CGIS for the Coast Guard.
The commander then has several paths: no action, administrative measures, nonjudicial punishment, or preferral of charges. NJP is called an Article 15 in the Army, Air Force and Space Force. It is captain's mast in the Navy and Coast Guard, and office hours in the Marine Corps. NJP is a commander's disciplinary action. It is not a court-martial and not a criminal conviction. It can still affect promotion, assignments, clearance eligibility, and the characterization of service if the servicemember is later administratively separated.
Preferral is the formal start of the court-martial process. A person subject to the UCMJ signs the charge sheet, DD Form 458, under oath. The convening authority then decides whether to refer the charges to trial and to which court. Before referral to a general court-martial, an Article 32 preliminary hearing is generally required.
There are three levels: summary, special and general court-martial. Article 92 offenses can be tried at any level. Once charges are preferred, a servicemember facing court-martial is entitled to detailed military defense counsel at no cost. Civilian defense counsel may also be retained at the servicemember's own expense. After a court-martial, review may extend to the service Court of Criminal Appeals and the United States Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces. Each has timeliness rules that run from events in the post-trial record.
Maximum Punishments Under Article 92: What Could Put Your Career or Future at Risk?
If you are trying to learn what a court-martial could impose for an Article 92 offense, the article itself does not answer that. As noted above, the limit is the one the President prescribes under Article 56(a). It is printed in the maximum punishment subparagraph of the Manual for Courts-Martial, Part IV, paragraph 18.
Those limits are set separately for the general-order offense and the other-order offense. Within dereliction, they also differ by the kind of dereliction alleged. The limit that matters is the one attached to the specification as charged, in the Manual edition applicable to the date of the alleged conduct.
The forum also matters. Summary, special and general courts-martial each have their own ceilings, whatever the offense. A punitive discharge can come only from a court-martial sentence, never from NJP or an administrative separation.
A maximum is a ceiling, not an expected sentence. Under 10 U.S.C. § 856(c)(1), a court-martial "shall impose punishment that is sufficient, but not greater than necessary." It must consider, among other things, "the nature and circumstances of the offense and the history and characteristics of the accused." A plea agreement may also limit the sentence.
A bad-conduct discharge and a dishonorable discharge are punitive discharges adjudged by court-martial. Dismissal is the punitive separation for commissioned officers. A punitive discharge, and in some situations an other than honorable characterization, can affect VA benefits, federal employment and civilian life long after any sentence ends.
Potential Defense Strategies Worth Exploring
If you are wondering where an Article 92 allegation can be contested, the answer starts with the elements. At court-martial, each element must be proved beyond a reasonable doubt. Where proof of one element fails, the specification fails.
- Unlawful order. An order that requires a crime, violates the Constitution, or lacks a valid military purpose is not a lawful order, and there is no duty to obey it.
- Knowledge. For the other-order offense, the government must prove the accused actually knew of the order. For dereliction, it must prove the accused knew or reasonably should have known of the duty.
- Ambiguity. An order or regulation too vague for a reasonable person to understand what it required may not support a conviction.
- Existence of the duty. For dereliction, the government must establish the specific duty alleged and its source. Duties can arise from regulations, orders, standard procedures and, in some circumstances, custom of the service.
- Inability to perform. A genuine inability to perform, through no fault of the accused, may negate the offense. So may the ineptitude line in the Manual quoted above.
- Obedience to orders. Military law recognizes this defense only in limited form. It generally does not protect someone who knew an order was unlawful, or where a person of ordinary sense and understanding would have known it was unlawful.
These defenses depend on the facts. Counsel typically begins with the charged language, the order or regulation itself, and the evidence of what the accused knew.
How Article 92 Relates to Other UCMJ Provisions in a Case Like Yours
For a servicemember whose conduct involved an officer, an NCO, or a regulation that touches another offense, the charge sheet may name more than one article. Under 10 U.S.C. § 890, Article 90 punishes anyone who "willfully disobeys a lawful command of that person's superior commissioned officer." In time of war it is punishable "by death or such other punishment as a court-martial may direct." At any other time, it is punishable by "such punishment, other than death, as a court-martial may direct." Article 90 requires willfulness and a superior commissioned officer. Prosecutors sometimes charge Article 90 and Article 92 in the alternative for the same conduct.
10 U.S.C. § 891, Article 91, applies to warrant officers and enlisted members. It covers striking or assaulting a warrant officer, noncommissioned officer or petty officer in the execution of office, willfully disobeying such a person's lawful order, and treating such a person with contempt or disrespect.
10 U.S.C. § 934, Article 134, reaches "disorders and neglects to the prejudice of good order and discipline," "conduct of a nature to bring discredit upon the armed forces," and "crimes and offenses not capital."
An attempted violation of a general order is a separate matter. The Manual, Part IV, paragraph 4 states it "should be charged under Article 80." It adds that the government need not prove intent to violate the order, but "must" prove intent "to commit the prohibited conduct."
Article 92 also appears alongside other charges, such as Article 86 absence without leave or Article 112a drug offenses, when the same conduct allegedly broke a specific order or regulation. A servicemember generally has the right to refuse NJP and be tried by court-martial instead, except when attached to or embarked in a vessel.
Facing Article 92 Charges? Here's What to Consider Next
When you first learn that an investigation or a charge exists, the earliest decisions usually concern statements and counsel. Under 10 U.S.C. § 831(b), no person subject to the UCMJ may question a suspect without first informing them "of the nature of the accusation." The suspect must also be told "that he does not have to make any statement regarding the offense" and that "any statement made by him may be used as evidence against him in a trial by court-martial."
This is not a Miranda warning. It applies to official questioning by anyone subject to the UCMJ, including someone in the chain of command, and it does not depend on custody. Under § 831(d), statements obtained in violation of the article are generally inadmissible against the person at court-martial.
On counsel, detailed defense counsel is a judge advocate assigned at no cost once charges are preferred. A civilian attorney who practices military law may be retained at any stage, including during the investigation. There are also limits on what a defense attorney can change. If NJP was accepted, the appeal window has closed and the record is final, an attorney has little ability to alter that outcome at that stage.
This page provides general information, not legal advice. Laws and regulations change; consult an attorney about your specific situation.
Reviewed by Thomas P. Matthews, Esq.
California Attorney | State Bar No. 163089
Content reviewed for general legal information only. This material does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship.